Looking for Something the Big Box Stores Don't Carry?
Your local hardware store and authorized Benjamin Moore retailer in Elmsford, NY. Before you spend hours wandering endless aisles, stop in and talk to us. We've got the specialty hardware, hard-to-find parts, quality paints, and decades of expert knowledge those chains just don't offer.
Walk-ins welcome • Free expert advice • No appointment needed
Looking for Something Specific?
Before you spend hours searching the aisles of a big box retailer, stop in and talk to us. Many of our customers come to us after striking out at larger chain stores. Whether it's a specialty fastener, replacement part, hard-to-find plumbing fitting, unique hardware item, paint accessory, or an older component that isn't commonly stocked anymore — we'll do our best to help you find exactly what you need.
What makes us different isn't just what's on our shelves — it's the decades of knowledge behind the counter.
Hard-to-Find Parts
Specialty hardware, replacement parts, unique fittings, and items larger retailers often don't stock.
Expert Recommendations
Get advice from experienced professionals who understand home repairs, painting projects, and contractor needs.
Local Convenience
Skip the long walks through giant warehouses and get in, get help, and get back to your project.
Solutions First
If we don't have it, we'll help point you in the right direction whenever possible.
Big Box Store
Endless Aisles
Wandering, searching, hoping
Elmsford Hardware
Expert Help in Minutes
Personal service, decades of knowledge
"Great selection of the old-school stuff most Home Depot and Lowe's don't have."
Customer Review
Need Help Finding Something?
Give us a call before making another trip to a big box store. We may already have exactly what you're looking for.
Show Us What You're Working On.
Take a photo of your project and get a clearer idea of what you may need before you come into the store. This is a color inspiration and project exploration tool — it helps you compare visual looks and build a shortlist for your store visit.
On-screen and printer color representations may vary from actual paint colors. This is a project exploration and color inspiration tool — not an exact color-matching or paint visualization system.
Everything You Need — and the Stuff Nobody Else Carries
From everyday essentials to those impossible-to-find items, we keep our shelves stocked with what our community actually needs.
Specialty Fasteners & Hardware
Bolts, screws, nuts, and fittings you won't find at the big box chains. Metric, SAE, and specialty threads in stock.
Plumbing Parts & Fittings
Hard-to-find replacement parts, unique fittings, valves, and older components for repairs and upgrades.
Benjamin Moore Paint & Supplies
Authorized Benjamin Moore retailer — quality paints, primers, brushes, rollers, and professional color-matching service in store.
Tools & Equipment
Hand tools, power tools, and workshop equipment for homeowners and contractors alike.
Key Cutting • Screen Repair • Special Orders • Expert Advice
We don't just sell products — we provide solutions. Can't find what you need? We'll special-order it or point you in the right direction.
See all products & servicesEverything You Need for a Complete Painting Project
Elmsford Hardware carries more than paint. From preparation to cleanup, we stock the tools and supplies to help you do the job right — all in one trip.
Brushes
Professional-grade brushes for every surface and finish type.
Rollers & Covers
Quality rollers for smooth, even coverage on walls and ceilings.
Surface Preparation
Sandpaper, scrapers, patching compound, and cleaning supplies.
Painter's Tape
Clean lines every time — tape for trim, edges, and delicate surfaces.
Caulk & Sealants
Fill gaps and seal joints before painting for a professional finish.
Drop Cloths & Protection
Protect floors, furniture, and fixtures during your project.
Visit or call the store to confirm specific product availability. On-screen and printer color representations may vary from actual paint colors.
Services at Elmsford Hardware
Contact Elmsford Hardware
Looking for something specific? Have a question about a project? Our team is here to help. Call us at (914) 592-6886 or send us a message — we'll get back to you fast.
Call Us
(914) 592-6886
Visit Us
21 E Main St
Elmsford, NY 10523
Store Hours
Mon–Fri: 8AM–4PM
Saturday: 9AM–2PM
Sunday: Closed
sgvenuti@optonline.net
Authorized Benjamin Moore Retailer
View our store on BenjaminMoore.com →
"Walk-ins welcome — but a quick call ahead can save you a trip. We'll let you know if we have what you need."
Send My Project Question
Tell us what you're working on — we'll check our inventory and get back to you.