Looking for Something the Big Box Stores Don't Carry?
Before you spend hours searching the aisles of a big box retailer, stop in and talk to us. Many of our customers come to us after striking out at larger chain stores. Whether it's a specialty fastener, replacement part, hard-to-find plumbing fitting, or an older component that isn't commonly stocked anymore — we'll do our best to help you find exactly what you need.
What Makes Us Different Isn't Just What's on Our Shelves
It's the decades of knowledge behind the counter. When you come to Elmsford Hardware looking for something specific, you're not wandering aisles — you're talking to someone who understands hardware, plumbing, fasteners, and repair parts.
Specialty Fasteners
Metric and SAE bolts, screws, nuts, washers, and specialty fasteners. We carry threads and sizes you won't find at the big chains.
Replacement Parts
Hard-to-find replacement hardware, plumbing fittings, valves, and older components for repairs and upgrades.
Unique Hardware Items
Specialty hardware, unique fittings, paint accessories, and items larger retailers often don't stock.
Older Components
Parts for older homes, fixtures, and equipment — the stuff that isn't commonly stocked anymore but we still carry or can source.
What Our Customers Come In For
NEEDS STORE CONFIRMATION — this list represents common hardware store categories. Specific inventory should be verified with Elmsford Hardware.
How It Works
Come to the Store
Bring your old part, a photo, or just describe what you need to one of our experienced team members.
We'll Help You Find It
We'll check our shelves and our network. If we have it, you walk out with it. If not, we'll help point you in the right direction.
Get Back to Your Project
Skip the long warehouse walks. Get in, get help, and get back to work — usually in minutes, not hours.
Need Help Finding Something?
Give us a call before making another trip to a big box store. We may already have exactly what you're looking for.